The Independent Business Journal

Roofing & Exteriors

Scott Barnhill looks at the whole house when a roof claim comes in

Scott Barnhill studied building code and insurance policies closely enough that on a hail job he checks the siding, windows and garage along with the roof.

Aerial view of a two-story white house with a dark shingle roof and attached garage in a Houston-area neighborhood
Photo: Clutch City Roofing & Siding

Scott Barnhill was tending bar at a fine dining restaurant when a friend pulled him into roofing. “Bartending is my real job and then roofing is my side job,” he says of how he saw the two at the time. The side job was supposed to add a line to his résumé, some experience to show the big companies he planned to approach once he finished his engineering studies at Texas A&M.

Then a big hailstorm hit. “I quit my bartending job the next day,” he says.

The side job outlasted the bar, and later a corporate job and a stint in tech as well. Today Barnhill owns Clutch City Roofing & Siding in Houston, where a hail claim is rarely only about shingles. “When we go, we’re looking at the siding, we’re looking at the windows, we’re looking at the garage,” he says. Every once in a while, he says, a normal roof replacement turns into “a full house makeover.” One friend’s claim ended up covering far more than the roof, and he says the house “looks brand new.” A homeowner whose insurer had first denied her roof described the same pattern in a review: Barnhill advised asking for a reinspection, and the claim ended with a new roof, 14 new windows and a replaced rear fence.

He came to that way of reading a claim from an odd direction. He had spent years in restaurants and bars and had no wish to manage one, so he went back to school as an older student, about 27 by his own count when roofing found him. He picked “the most difficult path imaginable,” engineering. The friend who got him into roofing sold shingles to contractors. One of those contractors needed project managers, and the friend told Barnhill the job could bend around a full-time student’s schedule.


Later work taught him the rest. He has written expert reports for law firms on at least 30 or 40 claims, he says. “Whenever they’re in litigation with an insurance company, the law firm has to hire an expert to come out and write the report,” he says. To do it, he dug into the International Residential Code and into what a policy covers. “I just learned a ton about what is covered in insurance and why things are tied together,” he says.

Those ties explain how a roofing company ended up doing remodels. Roofing, siding and windows so often sit inside one claim, he says, that he started taking on the rest of the work, among it a large remodel in Champions Forest. Most of the company’s work is residential, and Spring Branch is where he says it has made a good name. He has also roofed a large apartment complex and an airplane hangar.

The same habit of explaining shows up with shingles. Homeowners can get an insurance discount for Class 3 and Class 4 shingles, and Barnhill fills out the paperwork when they want it. First he walks them through what they are signing. The discount comes with what he calls a cosmetic exclusion: later hail damage can be treated as cosmetic, and the insurer may decline to replace the roof. “We at least explain to them, here’s why you may or may not want to get that discount,” he says. Sometimes the math favors it. For one homeowner saving about $1,000 a year on premiums, he pointed out that over the 14 years her last roof lasted, the savings would have come close to paying for a new one.

He tries to tell people what he would do himself. “If that were my house or my grandma’s house, I wouldn’t do that. Here’s what I would do,” he says. He talks homeowners through their options with samples and product literature, and on large projects he now brings a full presentation. Customers who had three or four roofers out have told him why they picked him, he says: he seemed the most honest and was easy to talk to.

He still remembers visiting a very elderly homeowner and holding back. “Hey, whatever you want to do, just let me know,” he told them, and promised he would not follow up unless they called. “I’m not in any way trying to pressure you into anything,” he told them. “That’s just kind of always how I’ve been,” he says.

His crews work from a record. Every job gets a project manager, and he says the team takes roughly 300 to 400 photos from the inspection through the install. When a homeowner wonders whether something was broken before the crew arrived, a photo taken before the work began settles it.

The attention to the customer’s side of the job came from tech. At a small startup of about 13 people, everyone did a bit of everything, and he watched coders build products from the ground up. Someone’s whole job there was customer success, and the handoff to that person was called “white glove onboarding.” He carried the idea onto rooftops. “It doesn’t matter if you put the best most awesome roof on someone’s house if you didn’t do a good job picking up at the end,” he says. When a homeowner calls, he asks for a name and address by text, texts back a time, and the visit lands on both calendars as an invite.

Three people work for him now, and a new hire learns by following him. “I’ll have them shadow me, three, four months, just hang out with me,” he says. They ride along on calls and watch how he does things. He remembers his own start, with one seminar behind him and the names of a roof’s components still to learn.

That start was a side job meant to dress up a résumé. “I tried to escape roofing before, but I feel like this is just what I’m good at,” he says. “This is what I know.”

More profiles